Sara Brighton, Savannah's rising star in the competitive culinary scene, is devastated when her historic riverside restaurant burns to the ground. Finding herself without the creative chaos that has defined her world for the last decade, she impulsively decides to pack up her life and return to McCall, Idaho, the last place she remembers being truly happy.

Sam Draper, head of the Lake Patrol division of McCall Police Department, is less than pleased to see another entitled tourist putting down roots in her picturesque hometown. Still, Sara surprises her by helping her swerve a professional disaster, and Sam returns the favor by teaching Sara to drive the ski boat languishing at the marina.

Their chemistry heats up under the summer sun, and they are falling in love, at least until Sara decides to buy her late father's iconic diner and turn it into yet another pretentious gastropub. Can they build a future amid the ghosts of the past that surround them?